Live · updated just now

Spotting talent and building talent are different jobs, review argues

Tuesday, 10 November 2026 · Sports psychology & performance · Full report · Evidence: Limited

What was found

This paper argues that two ideas often treated as one are actually different jobs. Talent identification tries to predict who will succeed later. Talent development is about how a person's skills and resources grow over time. The author says researchers and practitioners regularly use one in place of the other, for example treating a model built to track growth as if it could pick future winners, or the reverse. That mix-up weakens both studies and real-world programs 1. To fix this, the author proposes a "dual-path" approach. On the development path, each person's progress would be followed over time across factors such as thinking skills, physical traits, and social and emotional qualities. On the identification path, prediction models would be formally tested, and their use in real settings would be checked to see whether they actually work 1.

Who it applies to

The ideas are meant for anyone who spots or nurtures talent. That includes teachers and schools, sports coaches and academies, businesses choosing and training staff, and programs in the arts 1.

How strong the evidence is

Early. This is a literature review that sets out a conceptual framework, not a study that collected new data 1. No sample size applies, and the abstract reports no testing of the proposed approach on real people or groups. Its case rests on reasoning and on reading earlier work rather than on measured results from programs that used the framework. Only the abstract was read, because the full text is not openly available. Details of which studies were reviewed and how the argument is built could not be checked.

What it means in practice

People who run talent programs should be clear about which goal they are pursuing at any moment 1. When the aim is to choose people, they should rely on prediction tools that have been tested and shown to hold up in practice. When the aim is to help people grow, they should follow each individual over time and track changes in several areas, rather than relying on a single snapshot. Keeping these two tasks separate may lead to fairer selection and better support. Because the framework has not yet been tested, it is best treated as a useful way to organize thinking and planning, not as a proven method.