Big review of beauty websites shows what makes online shopping easy
Wednesday, 18 November 2026 · Marketing & design · Full report · Evidence: Moderate
What was found
The Baymard Institute, a research group that studies how people use shopping websites, rated the online shopping experience of ten health and beauty brands 1. No brand reached a "good" rating. Seven landed in the "mediocre" tier: Ulta Beauty, CHANEL, Glossier, Jones Road, Sephora, Twice, and Walgreens. Two, CVS and Harry's, were rated "poor." One, the online pharmacy Shop Apotheke, was rated "broken," the lowest level 1. Even large, well-known retailers fell short of a solid shopping experience.
Who it applies to
The findings cover the shopping websites and mobile apps of health and beauty sellers, including makeup, skincare, grooming, and pharmacy brands 1. They matter most to the companies running these sites and the designers who build them. They also matter to shoppers who buy these products online.
How strong the evidence is
Moderate. Reviewers checked each brand's site by hand against a fixed set of usability standards 1. The project includes more than 6,000 individual scores and more than 4,500 examples of good design practice. Between 29 and 104 page designs were reviewed per brand 1. Several limits apply. Only ten brands were reviewed, so the results may not reflect the whole industry. Mobile apps were assessed for just two brands, Ulta Beauty and Sephora. Only the headline and a short, cut-off snippet were read for this summary, so the full method and context of the testing are not known here.
What it means in practice
Health and beauty shopping sites often make buying harder than it needs to be, on both computers and phones. Many brands have clear room to improve how their pages are laid out and how customers move from browsing to checkout 1. For businesses, the more than 4,500 best-practice examples offer concrete models to learn from. For shoppers, the ratings suggest that frustration on these sites is common and not a matter of user error. Companies that fix basic usability problems may stand out in a field where no competitor has yet reached a good rating.